4 Comments
User's avatar
⭠ Return to thread
Martin Greenwald, M.D.'s avatar

Discourses on Livy is criminally underrated.

Expand full comment
Tommaso di Maria's avatar

We are understanding one another, Dr. Greenwald.

Expand full comment
Christopher F. Rufo's avatar

I recently read Discourses for the first time. Lots of insight packed in there. And I was somewhat surprised to see that Machiavelli is something of an idealist, says the republic is the ideal form, although not always possible. Sense of the tragic, governance in the face of bad options.

Expand full comment
Tommaso di Maria's avatar

One of the great "virtues" of Machiavelli is that he is oriented toward the classics, despite his disagreements with them. Put differently, he cannot be properly viewed through or via the technocratic mentality - he is prior to, and more fundamental. He is free of all gnostic tendencies or false moralisms.

Expand full comment