60 Comments
User's avatar
Deidre K's avatar

Carol Swain- an intellectual with common sense. A rare gem.

Expand full comment
CC's avatar

I have always admired her graciousness...

Expand full comment
Joe Horton's avatar

It’s not as rare as it looks. What’s rare is for them to be noticed. Raving maniacs tell you they’re “intellectuals,” but really aren’t. The others quietly state the truth and let the rest figure it out. The maniacs keep screaming the lies at you, hoping you’ll start believing them.

Expand full comment
Clever Pseudonym's avatar

Carol Swain for President!

Expand full comment
Bee's avatar

Well, she thought the 2020 election was stolen. If she lost, we might not have enough courts on the land to certify she lost.

Expand full comment
John Smith's avatar

Excellent work! There is no doubt that a White male would already be gone.

Expand full comment
pokipsy christiansen's avatar

I object to capitalizing white or black, except as part of a proper name. The people you describe by these crude categories are not nations, nor do they inherently share anything but color. These words are not proper proper nouns. It is subjugation of language to political impulse. Stop it.

Expand full comment
John Smith's avatar

I will stop it when the woketards stop capitalizing all races but White. FO

Expand full comment
pokipsy christiansen's avatar

I zorp thee back to kindergarten. I don't care who started it. Vamoo!

Expand full comment
Michael Miller's avatar

Hey John: what does FO mean?

Expand full comment
Holly Hart's avatar

Probably "f--k off".

Expand full comment
Cynthia M's avatar

Absolutely, positively, totally agree.

Expand full comment
VikingMom's avatar

"A white male would probably already be gone."

And that really says everything, doesn't it? Color blind should mean exactly what it says and the standards by which people are judged should be the same, regardless of their race, religion, or gender!

Expand full comment
SlothB77's avatar

A white male would not make it to that position anymore.

Expand full comment
CC's avatar

No joke - ditto 'corporate boards'. My husband is an esteemed academic and ran a large business consultancy for over 8 years in the securities litigation area. When it came time to step back I suggested he seek a board appointment. He consulted an agency which places people in such positions and he was told point-blank that as a white male his chances of landing a spot were very low indeed. It's a shame, as he has such a wealth of knowledge and experience in his area of expertise. Our world has abandoned merit and intellect for more superficial qualities that don't really matter when it comes to running a business.

Expand full comment
Tommaso di Maria's avatar

The lady is restrained in her reaction, given all of the circumstances. I favor her method of looking at the overall patterns of conduct and responsibility - that Ms. Gay appears to have patterned her entire academic career on Prof. Swain's work.

Expand full comment
Project Luminas's avatar

Appears to indeed. Her condition for remaining as Harvard president should be to facilitate regular workshops and teach courses on plagiarism...using her own dissertation as course readings. Swain could be a guest lecturer...

Expand full comment
Sam's avatar

Excellent work, I feel momentum building, we’re, you, are finally moving forward against the woke mind virus.

Expand full comment
Dave's avatar

Today she would have had ChatGPT do her work.

Expand full comment
Joe Horton's avatar

Or perhaps that’s all she actually is: an AI version 1.01 in something that partly resembles a human body.

Expand full comment
steven lightfoot's avatar

Certainly, a white male would already be gone.

Expand full comment
Michaela McKuen's avatar

Yes, but Carol Swain also isn't Gay! *Badum tish*

Expand full comment
Joe Horton's avatar

Good one, boss!

Expand full comment
Benjamin Holm's avatar

Progressives basically think they own minorities. Their votes are rightfully theirs. Apostates when they don't.

Expand full comment
pokipsy christiansen's avatar

Yes. You got one. Mighty hunted.

But what we here want to know is -

When will the orange fool be punted?

Expand full comment
Strategy Pattern (Don’t Laugh)'s avatar

Claudine Gay is Vogue; Carol Swain is not. Plagiarism is so hot right now.

Expand full comment
CC's avatar

Ask Joe BIDEN - he's the 'Plagiarist in Chief' having ripped off many people including Neil Kinnock, Robert Kennedy, Hubert Humphrey and JFK. BIDEN had to withdraw from a Presidential run in 1988 because of his 'snatching' other people’s words. But Democrats consider plagiarism to be a feather-in-the-cap, as they just don't care anymore about morals and merit.

Expand full comment
Strategy Pattern (Don’t Laugh)'s avatar

As I said: so hot right now.

Expand full comment
Bee's avatar

The study replication crisis and plagiarism is a problem within the Academy.

Expand full comment
Ellerslie's avatar

Excellent work, and this follow up with Carol Swain is dynamite. I love the way she defines herself as "mainstream"! Absolutely! Elise Stefanik is commenting on X that the "mainstream" media is not covering her plagiarism. I don't know as I gave up on MSM a long time ago. But it sounds plausible. God grant your scoop breaks through that particular "glass ceiling"!

Expand full comment
Garry Dale Kelly's avatar

>>>>affirmative action should be means-tested and race-neutral<<<<<

INDEED

Expand full comment
Dennis's avatar

She needs to resign in disgrace, but she also did America a great service by awakening her to the depths of rot at the ideological altar inherent in every (formerly) prestigious institution. We must do better. Gay is merely an intersectional foot soldier in this war warping our society.

Expand full comment