262 Comments
User's avatar
Bryan Leed's avatar

I love the choice of JD Vance with Trump!

It's interesting that Vance is already known to the public because of his best selling autobiography, hillbilly elegy, that was also made into a Netflix film.

I live near Dayton Ohio, where I grew up also. Much of hillbilly elegy is social commentary that rings very true from my experience.

I used to make deliveries in Middletown, where much of JD's childhood took place. JD briefly lived in Miamisburg, Ohio, where I used to have a full-time job in Miamisburg.

I can confirm that all of what JD talks about socially and culturally has been accurate in my life experience as well.

Trump and Vance are working for the common man! A strong and conservative USA means a safer planet politically, the USA leads the way or else nobody does!

Meanwhile, all the Democrats and world elites seek to enslave or cull the common man, in the USA and the western world; because they know a strong USA stands in their way of dominating and oppressing the entire planet and human population.

Expand full comment
Christopher F. Rufo's avatar

Great comment!

Expand full comment
Double Mc's avatar

Especially the final paragraph. It's the message the everyday, non-elite Democrat voter needs to hear.

Expand full comment
MaryAnn Markowitz's avatar

Our Democrat family members seem like they soak up as much visceral hatred and then call us to say we are crazy.

Expand full comment
Foot's avatar

How long do you think before Vance gets replaced on the ticket?

Expand full comment
JWSPOONERMD's avatar

Ridiculous question…

Expand full comment
Pangolin Chow Mein's avatar

Vance showed great courage railing against Bush/Cheney is his acceptance speech…I’m pretty sure now that Biden has dropped out Vance will vote for Kamala because Trump surrounded himself with neocons like Bolton and Pompeo and Tillerson.

Expand full comment
JWSPOONERMD's avatar

Baloney

Expand full comment
Yuri Bezmenov's avatar

Rufo for Secretary of Education?

Expand full comment
Christopher F. Rufo's avatar

Rumors are circulating…

Expand full comment
Joe Smith's avatar

The Former Secretary of the...

Former Education Department has a ring to it.

Expand full comment
Mitch's avatar

this.

Expand full comment
InquizitiveOne's avatar

Yes! End the Dept of Education

Expand full comment
CMCM's avatar

Yes! I don't for the life of me see the need for the D. of Education when every single state has its own Board of Education.

Expand full comment
carily myers's avatar

lol, like

Expand full comment
Hektor Bleriot's avatar

School's out forEVER!

Expand full comment
Jessica's avatar

👏🏻

Expand full comment
Faith&FitnessMama's avatar

Please, let it be so!

Expand full comment
Notes from the Under Dog L.'s avatar

Best person for the job!

Expand full comment
Richard Bicker's avatar

And working tirelessly to put himself out of one job and into another in four years' time...

Expand full comment
CC's avatar

Abolish the position!!!

Expand full comment
JasonT's avatar

In a sane world there would be no Dept of Education and thus no Sec. of Education. That would be a Day 2 XO.

Expand full comment
Pangolin Chow Mein's avatar

Nostrovia!!

Expand full comment
Richard Tavares Bosshardt's avatar

Chris, As a long time follower, I think your analysis is spot on. I think that JD does balance the ticket and brings a degree and type of credibility to Trump's candidacy that it was lacking and that some diversity selection would not have. Even cynics of both men realize that they now have to dig deeper to understand what is happening in the Republican party. When I voted for Trump in 2016, I had to hold my nose so-to-speak to make that choice, but Hillary was an absolute no and I did want to waste my vote on some hopeless write-in protest vote. Having observed how Trump governed I was surprised at how many reasonable, sensible, and moderate positions he took despite fighing a continuous pitched battle against both a visible and invisible unhinged resistance. I voted for him in 2020 and remain unconvinced that it was the most secure election ever. Millions of educated, center right voters like me feel the same. If not for covid, Trump would have won handily. This time, I will cast my vote and pray for the safety of both men and their administration. God help us if the Democrats pull off a miracle and Kamala wins.

Rick Bosshardt MD, FACS ( richardtbosshardtmd.substack.com )

Expand full comment
Brian McKibben's avatar

Your comments sound like the 60% of voters in the middle who are ignored by the mainstream media. If Trump and Vance speak calmly and rationally to the middle, they will win in a landslide.

If they take any of the shouting divisive (anti-civilization) bait laid for them by the mainstream media, then they will lose.

Expand full comment
VikingMom's avatar

Agree 100%! There are millions of people who are looking for someone to vote FOR, rather than simply being forced to vote AGAINST people, as we so often are!

Expand full comment
Christopher F. Rufo's avatar

Thanks

Expand full comment
Pangolin Chow Mein's avatar

Yes, I especially liked how Trump relinquished the office of the presidency in March 2020 and made Fauci emperor for life!! No other president would have prioritized playing golf and fucking porn stars over protecting the American people!

Expand full comment
c Anderson's avatar

I enjoy 😉the style you progressives use to win friends and influence people!

Expand full comment
Brian's avatar

You misspelled "Communists."

Expand full comment
c Anderson's avatar

👍

Expand full comment
JWSPOONERMD's avatar

You weren’t the brightest in your class, were you?

Expand full comment
James N. Miller's avatar

With Vance we have a chance for a realignment around a multiethnic, working-class conservatism. Not a blind ideological adherence to free market capitalism that ignores communities and families, or the role of a (limited) government. Quoting from Oren Cass in a 2021 article in Foreign Affairs: "Markets reduce people to their material interests and reduce relationships to transactions. They prioritize efficiency to the exclusion of resilience, sentiment, and tradition. Shorn of constraints, they often reward the most socially corrosive behaviors and can quickly undermine the foundations of a stable community—for instance, pushing families to commit both parents to full-time market labor or strip-mining talent from across the nation and consolidating it in a narrow set of cosmopolitan hubs. For conservatism, then, markets are a valuable mechanism for sustaining and advancing a flourishing society. But they should never be an end unto themselves. And their quality is contingent on the norms and rules by which they function and the vitality of the other institutions operating alongside them."

Expand full comment
Richard Bicker's avatar

Ah yes, the Wesley Mouch solution. Mouch's "norms and rules" always have our best interests at heart, even as we find ourselves out of work, out of our homes, and out of any chance raising a family and living a decent life. Go Wesley!

Expand full comment
George Cervenka's avatar

Who needs free markets? Apparently no one according to the Republicans. Vance has been called a conservative mystic. That much is true. If you have read Dr. Leonard Peikoff’s “DIM Hypothesis”, Vance and his ilk fit the “Misintegrate Mode” to “T”. Mixtures can be dangerous, mixtures of church and state are deadly. Can the right ever get that?

Expand full comment
Richard Bicker's avatar

It's a tough argument to make to those incapable of reading let alone understanding Peikoff and other Randians/Objectivists. You know, the same salt-of-the-earth folks who want the government out of their lives but LOVE their Social Security and Medicare. Kinda tough for Trump and Vance to argue "Give us power so we can sit around and do NOTHING!" Well, not quite nothing—more along the lines of "fixin' to but waitin' on" (as they say in Dixie) thus providing the time needed to heal the nation's thoroughly corrupted "markets." BTW, just how long does the good doctor along with his confederates believe that recovery process will take, especially unaided by an even more muscular and thus potentially (assuredly) ruinous federal government?

Expand full comment
George Cervenka's avatar

The Ayn Rand Institute is accomplishing quite a lot to spread Objectivism, particularly to the young people. And people like Alex Epstein, in particular, have made some tremendous gains in the field of energy. It is promising to see people unafraid to speak out for reason, individual rights and capitalism.

Expand full comment
Richard Bicker's avatar

When challenged, people like you ALWAYS revert to the theoretical—the alternate universe where O-ism is converting the multitudes and will soon reign supreme. I rub your nose in the real world for a good reason: Trump and Vance, in order to make ANY progress on advancing your dreams, require practical answers to the hard political questions they face. As usual, nothing is forthcoming from the pointy headed folks except admiration and hopes pinned on other pointy headed folks. And the world goes round and down.

Expand full comment
George Cervenka's avatar

Oh, I am now a “you people”. Adios.

Expand full comment
JWSPOONERMD's avatar

Foreign Affairs is a leftist propaganda publication; you know that, right? Government is good; Free Markets are bad is the Foreign Affairs contention. I used to subscribe to FA until I realized the leftist ideology underlying their arguments.

Expand full comment
Pangolin Chow Mein's avatar

Yes, I still can’t believe we supported Bush in 2000 who stole the election and failed to prevent 9/11 and lied us into an asinine war all the while selling us out to China!?! Uh, maybe we should stop voting?? 😉

Expand full comment
JWSPOONERMD's avatar

Yes, you should stop voting.

Expand full comment
Graham Cunningham's avatar

"Trump has a magnetic attachment to the masses—think of his archetypal Rust Belt voter—while Vance holds appeal to a sector of the elite." A great observation on the complexity of political psychology.

Expand full comment
c Anderson's avatar

Yale almost ruined Vance. He failed to understand the genius of DJT. How interesting that he is a recovering Ivy League zombie. I say recovering because that indoctrination runs deep. The unique nature of this is that Trump sees the “rust belt” people as the genius behind his successes. The trades built his empire.

Expand full comment
Christopher F. Rufo's avatar

👍

Expand full comment
Ian Campbell's avatar

JD's experience at Yale reinforces my admiration for and appreciation of Amy Chua. Though I have to wonder how is she not miserable at Yale.

Expand full comment
Pangolin Chow Mein's avatar

And Bush saw you as dupes to assrape (figuratively)…but at least torturing and slaughtering innocent Muslims brought a little joy to your otherwise dreary existence. 😘

Expand full comment
Pangolin Chow Mein's avatar

Nope, I know exactly who sacrificed 7000 Americans so he could win a second term.

Expand full comment
c Anderson's avatar

The only true words uttered by radical leftist Jesse Jackson: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=lsjLUS0Lt-8

Expand full comment
Jamal X's avatar

Trump owes money to many of those who worked in the trades—to many contractors and vendors. You are very comical and delusional. 🤡

Expand full comment
JWSPOONERMD's avatar

You obviously have no meaningful business background, do you?

Expand full comment
Jamal X's avatar

I used to evaluate white-collar criminals for prison, including narcissistic sociopaths like Donald Trump. Now, I'm successfully retired.😂🤣😅

Expand full comment
JWSPOONERMD's avatar

So, when did you evaluate Donald Trump? I’m retired but I am Boarded with the American Board of Psychiatry and Neurology. Spent many hours on psychiatric wards evaluating sociopathic/psychopathic personality disorders, among many others. You’re preoccupied (OCD?) with Trump’s idiosyncrasies wrongly relying on your prior work. Yet you are likely ignorant of economics, political philosophy, military intelligence. I’ll bet you think Kamala’s “price controls” ideas are super, right? Can you intelligently challenge Trump’s prior successes or his policy proposals?

Expand full comment
Jamal X's avatar

I once evaluated a tricky psychiatrist for possible imprisonment under California Penal Code 1203.03 for overprescribing psychotropics. After our initial interview, he boasted to other inmates on

the prison yard about how he had deceived me and the clinical psychologist. Inmates on the yard later shared this information with me and the clinical psychologist. During the second interview, he cried like a little bitch on his knees in my office. I explained yo him he couldn't behave that way during his interactions with other inmates on the yard with certainty of having a sexual predator's large d%$k violently inserted into his butt followed by sutures and indefinite bed rest. 😂🤣😅

Expand full comment
Jamal X's avatar

I used to evaluate white-collar criminals for prison, including narcissistic sociopaths like Donald Trump.😂🤣😅

Expand full comment
Tolerance Is Lazy's avatar

How much does he owe, to whom, and why?

Expand full comment
Jamal X's avatar

Additionally, 45 will likely face prison time after the next election. He's not done with the criminal justice system.

Expand full comment
Christopher F. Rufo's avatar

Thanks

Expand full comment
Steve's avatar

Something a lot of people don't get. Vance was not Just A Maine, He got out as a Corporal (E-4), Not an Officer. People who have not served don't grasp the difference, between Em's & Officers. 2 different worlds.

Expand full comment
Art's avatar

It’s interesting that Vance and Rob Henderson had similar trajectories, and both rejected the political and social elitism that has disenfranchised middle and working class people for generations.

Expand full comment
Steve's avatar

Could it be they think middle and working class people are stupid. I spent my working life on the factory floor, making Stuff. They are NOT Stupid, just different interests. One of the complaints we read about Donald Trump is The Way He Talks. He talks just like so many people I worked with (the name calling Lying Ted, Small Hands Marco, Sleepy Joe) Chops WILL be busted, and if you can't deal with that, you won't last long.

Expand full comment
Sonsoles de Lacalle's avatar

I think also because they are grounded on common sense, “experiential” if you wish, that comes from reflecting on reality… that brings a look at mankind that has realism and compassion…. Both men seem to operate on a different anthropological realm than the “elites” hungry for power.

Expand full comment
TDF's avatar

I've always said what people forget is that Trump is a New Yorkah. They are Brash, Opinionated and Filterless. This is what resonates with the working class, the ability to tell someone to "GFY" one minute but yet have their back the next. I grew up in a blue collar city north of Boston, we talk to each other just like that all the time.

Expand full comment
Steve's avatar

I'm retired now, and I Do Miss That.

Expand full comment
Dawn I. Martin's avatar

I’ve made this comparison a number of times! Vance & Henderson, as well as Rufo, are very important voices for our future. And, I’m a Baby Boomer saying that!

Expand full comment
Pacificus's avatar

Yeah. Never trust anyone above the rank of about colonel. That's when the professional ass-kissing starts, from what I can tell.

Expand full comment
Christopher F. Rufo's avatar

🎯

Expand full comment
JWSPOONERMD's avatar

But still Marines.

Expand full comment
Steve's avatar

I was in the Air Force. It Was Really Tough! How many times were the salad forks not properly chilled, and serving White Wine with Beef Stroganoff! The Horror, The Horror!

/Perpetuating The Myth

Expand full comment
gloxinia's avatar

Great analysis, but even better was your take on Kamala. She is a wolf in sheep’s clothing and has been wearing that stupid, cackling wool suit for 4 years, just waiting for her moment to disrobe it and reveal her true self. No one should underestimate her or those who buttress her ambitions and motives. Whoever wrote her acceptance speech you referred to, did so with her full input. It was a master class in diabolical tease of what is yet to come. Vance is a smart, savvy guy who hopefully can see what you see, Christopher, and help Trump steer the ship away from what they have planned. And, btw, your work definitely deserves a seat at the table.

Expand full comment
Christopher F. Rufo's avatar

Yes: Do not underestimate Kamala!

Expand full comment
carily myers's avatar

agree, she's a shark in a silly dolphin costume

Expand full comment
Pangolin Chow Mein's avatar

Remember when Trump told Stormy how much he hated sharks right before he fucked her without a condom while Melania was preggers??

Expand full comment
Jamal X's avatar

Kamala prosecuted individuals like Donald Trump for sex-related offenses and fraud in California. During my 34-year career in corrections in California, I had narcissistic sociopaths like Donald Trump on my prison caseload.

Expand full comment
JWSPOONERMD's avatar

You obviously didn’t learn much in your job about “narcissistic psychopaths.” Your diagnostic skills suck. You don’t like Trump, but don’t sound stupid and prejudice as a former corrections officer. your profession doesn’t necessarily have a stellar reputation.

Expand full comment
Midlife Musings's avatar

Thanks for your positive commentary on JD Vance. The opposition has already started their smears and untruths. I think he’s a great American success story. Whips smart and well spoken.

Expand full comment
Joe Smith's avatar

Can I get an Amen for Rufo in this new Counter-Elite!?

Expand full comment
Christopher F. Rufo's avatar

I’m working hard on building this.

Expand full comment
Sabrina LaBow's avatar

It is really ironic that Trump comes from money and Vance does not yet it is Trump who appeals to the rust belt and Vance to the elite. It is a strong ticket. The problem they both seem to have is watching what they say with regard to women. Calling then dumb as rocks and childless cat people is not helpful and as we know, that's all the press will focus on. They must focus on policy, policy, policy. The border, border, border. sabrinalabow.substack.com

Expand full comment
Christopher F. Rufo's avatar

Agreed!

Expand full comment
Joe Smith's avatar

The Cat Lady thing was an email to a friend, years ago. One whom he took bake goods to, in the hospital. That "Friend" has since Transgendered... and unfriended Vance.

Context is 🔑

Expand full comment
Sabrina LaBow's avatar

I know it's unfair. The MSM doesn't care about context as we know. They would find fault with anyone who was on the ticket. I just think going forward, stick to the policies. However I may be wrong with that suggestion as it looks like Trump is going to lean in and hammer her. These next few months are going to be a bumpy ride!

Expand full comment
BillR's avatar

Bravo!

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Jul 27
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
Christopher F. Rufo's avatar

Correct

Expand full comment
Fabius Minarchus's avatar

Bingo! Trump lacked think tank support last go around, and he doesn't speak Bureaucrat.

Two and a half years ago I wrote:

"The Republican Party needs to up its ideological game and craft an agenda that can appeal to the younger generations. This starts with weeding out long festering internal contradictions. You cannot expect the unskilled to get off welfare when it takes two jobs to make up the lost revenue. You cannot fight radical feminism when it takes two incomes to support a middle class lifestyle. You cannot expect young adults to abide by traditional notions of family values when they cannot afford to start a family.

"If you want capitalism and democracy at the same time, you need to mix in a healthy dose of populism. The sweet spot for smaller government is somewhere between Ron Paul and Ross Perot, with a bit of Teddy Roosevelt thrown in for good measure (Sorry Glenn!). If we want to keep America capitalist, we need to increase the number of capitalists, and that means taking positions which will Trigger both die hard Reagan fans and my younger Libertarian self. Saving America is not a job for Snowflakes, including right wing Snowflakes like P.J. and John Kaisich.

"Donald Trump got it. He used his fame and fortune to drag the Republican Party kicking and screaming towards the political niche it needs to be in. Unfortunately, the bravery and belligerence which enabled Trump to face down the Man Behind the Curtain made him frightening to the wine-and-cheese set. Many longtime Republican intellectuals couldn't handle the excess testosterone and defected to Team Biden. And Trump's Man of the People rambling rhetoric came off as incoherent to the college educated.

"Trump's biggest weakness was with the college educated demographic—including the top bureaucrats who run the Deep State. His biggest failures as President stem from his lack of think tank support. Trump was doing battle against not just Democrats and Big Media; he was battling against basic textbooks, and he was hopelessly outgunned."

https://rulesforreactionaries.substack.com/p/a-call-for-counter-revolution

I was hoping Trump would pick Vance for these reasons. There may be hope for America yet.

Expand full comment
Pangolin Chow Mein's avatar

Trump and Bush spent like crazy and blew up the debt!! But at least we got to slaughter a few Muslims!! Totes worth it!!!

Expand full comment
Marie G's avatar

And all areas of government, the left have infiltrated. We must do the same.

The country needs conservative voices in all institutions, especially government and universities. If I must pose as a lefty to get the job, so be it.

Expand full comment
Christopher F. Rufo's avatar

Agreed.

Expand full comment
Joel's avatar

First is to cull the numbers. Trim out everything at the regional level and up destroy the incestuous situation in our government administration

Expand full comment
Luke Lea's avatar

What this new counter elite lacks going forward, at least in my opinion, is a programatic vision of the future, something tangible that appeals to the imagination as well as to the social and economic needs of ordinary working- and middle-class Americans: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00U0C9HKW

The war on wokeness is just the first step.

Expand full comment
Marie G's avatar

Perhaps project 2025 will be the answer

Expand full comment
Patricia GR's avatar

Your words back up what I have been trying to say for awhile! JD is a perfect choice for all the reasons you state. Excellent analysis. And another substack writer owes me a bag of popcorn.

Expand full comment
William Martin's avatar

Good comments.

By the way, how embarrassed does the USA mass media have to get before moving toward some common sense, logical manner of presenting their "news & commentary"? Is it a political bias or IQ deficiency, as if they can belief it - and they must think vacuous viewers might buy it?

Expand full comment
Hawker's avatar

The likes of CNN, MSNBC , NYT etc are both IQ deficient and bias.

Expand full comment
John Gelb's avatar

I don’t know exact timing, but there is an incredible synchronicity between Trump’s selection of JDV and the a16z founder’s podcast episode in support of Trump…arguably the most important tech-focused startup VC firm in USA. Four years ago this would have been unthinkable

Expand full comment
Christopher F. Rufo's avatar

It’s not by accident.

Expand full comment
MeriBear's avatar

But what we have been through in the past four years would also have been unthinkable a mere ten years prior. Who we are now is due to the crucible the Elites foisted onto the world. Many of us saw it for what it was and stood firm, raised our voices, and a lot of red pilling has occurred. I agree with A, “it had to be this way.” People would not have awakened to see the Matrix. There are some who never will. My own brother. It is sad but he doesn’t want to know. His identity depends on the lies he has assumed, like a mantle, his entire life. It takes courage to resist that, or walk away from that, and not everyone has the courage to do that.

Expand full comment
MeriBear's avatar

Q

Expand full comment
Ed Y.'s avatar

Nothing can stop what is coming…

Expand full comment
carily myers's avatar

AMEN

Expand full comment
Pangolin Chow Mein's avatar

Yeah, Theil and Palantir aren’t the Deep State or anything. No red flag there. 😝

Expand full comment